Welcome to Scrutiny – a place for debate and discussion on politics today.

Let’s not revisit the oil con

Scottish Policy, UK Policy Jul 25, 2013 5 Comments

Nationalising Scotland’s oil is not a priority – stopping multinationals and their pals in the Treasury fleecing us again in the renewables field as they did in oil is: Robin McAlpine’s article from today’s Scotsman

Read more »

A New Economic Model for Scotland

Scottish Policy Jul 14, 2013 6 Comments

Robin Hahnel and Gar Alperovitz are two of the major figures in the New Economic movement in the US. We are very lucky to have them writing on the Common Weal and Scotland’s economic future – from today’s Sunday Herald

Read more »

A post-stone age economy

Scottish Policy Jun 30, 2013 2 Comments

A teaser from the Scottish Left Review which will be out next week. Jim Mather argues that the model of financialised capitalism has very clearly failed to address the ‘Common Weal’ either in terms of shared wealth or economy security. A new approach is needed.

Read more »

Work for the Common Weal

Left Strategy, Scottish Policy, UK Policy Jun 27, 2013 1 Comment

We need a new economic philosophy, one where people come together for the benefit of all members of society – Scotsman article from today

Read more »

Welfare state of mind

Scottish Policy, UK Policy Jun 14, 2013 Add a comment

My Scotsman article – Political leaders and their parties have to be told to stop parroting what the plutocrats want them to say and start doing what the people who elected them told them to

Read more »

Iain Banks: the left loses a great supporter

Uncategorized Jun 10, 2013 1 Comment

RIP Iain Banks, a true supporter of the Scottish left

Read more »

Economy plan chained by convention

Scottish Policy, UK Policy May 27, 2013 Add a comment

Belatedly – my piece in The Scotsman the Scottish Government economic paper: The SNP’s plan, while recognising some of what not to do, seems to include repeating the mistakes that caused the economic crisis in the first place

Farage debacle a chill wind for Scottish politics

Scottish Policy, UK Policy May 20, 2013 1 Comment

The response to a protest against an anti-immigration, xenophobic political party has been as hard to believe as it has been distorted. The impact on Scottish politics is alarming.

Read more »

What next for ‘Common Weal’?

Left Strategy, Scottish Policy May 06, 2013 5 Comments

It has been a promising start to a project to outline the details of a better Scotland. But now it is for others to shape the path forward.

Read more »

The difference between disclosure and transparency

Scottish Policy, UK Policy Apr 17, 2013 1 Comment

Disclosure is telling facts; transparency is telling facts with the expectation that you will be held to account. Why does Better Together not seem to know the difference?

Read more »