Welcome to Scrutiny – a place for debate and discussion on politics today.

Entirely neutral government statistics? Really? Where?

Political Parties, Scottish Policy, UK Policy Feb 03, 2012 Add a comment

In today’s Scotsman academic Arthur Midwinter claims that the Scottish Government is not being honest about statistics. This would not make them an isolate case…

Read more »

This is real progress in the reform of universities

Scottish Policy Feb 02, 2012 Add a comment

Rector-elect of Edinburgh University looks at the proposals for reform of the governance of universities and finds a promising start.

Read more »

Parliamentary democracy and the art of the expected

Political Parties, Scottish Policy, UK Policy Feb 02, 2012 Add a comment

Sometimes it really is a bit galling to hear Westminster politicians criticising the level of scrutiny at Holyrood – and today is one of those days…

Read more »

Why amn’t I cheering about the lynching of Goodwin?

Scottish Policy, UK Policy Feb 01, 2012 1 Comment

People on the left might be expected to be first in line to celebrate the removal of Fred Goodwin’s knighthood – but we know a distraction when we see one…

Read more »

Can’t see the poverty for the knighthoods

Political Parties, Scottish Policy Jan 31, 2012 Add a comment

Not only is Knighthood-gate a distraction from the rest of the annual bonus round, can it be a coincidence it comes as the Welfare Bill makes the commons?

Read more »